Decades of records missing from Indiana University Bloomington

enter image description here

Indiana University’s Archives hold decades of administrative records from the English Department. I have copies of some of them: a 1951 committee report, a memo from 1966 convening a creative writing committee, a report of that committee’s meeting listing who attended and what they decided, and a 1972 committee agenda. The department’s own collection at the Archives includes committee minutes, memorandum, correspondence and agendas through 1999.

I’m trying to find out what happened to those records after 1999.

Since late 2024, I’ve asked IU under Indiana’s public records law for the IUB English Department’s meeting minutes, agendas and memos from 2000 to 2006. I’ve gotten three different answers. In January 2026, IU said it couldn’t find them. In September, it said the department doesn’t keep records of meetings more than 20 years old. In October, on the last page of their response to the state’s Public Access Counselor, IU said the department didn’t take minutes until 2017 or 2018, so the records -purportedly- never existed.

And then there are the responses from the various faculty members I interviewed who openly cited hostility toward public disclosure. Those responses stated all departments keep minutes or memoranda, but they do not disclose them to the public. After I pointed out these records are public records, most of these faculty members changed the subject or suddenly ended the conversation.

These answers can’t all be true. You can’t lose records that were never made. And the Archives show the department was recording its meetings long before 2017.

This isn’t the only time. When I asked for a faculty roster from my years at IU, I was told no such record existed. I later found the information on IU’s own Registrar website, which publishes historical course-section data listing instructors by course and term.

IU’s records office has also told me that records kept by a department are supposed to go to the Archives, not be discarded, and that departments aren’t required to take minutes. That may be true. It still leaves a question: what happened to the department’s records since the year 2000? IU’s records guidelines say records aren’t to be disposed of until the Archives has reviewed them for historical value.

That question isn’t only about minutes. Departments send memos and letters to each other and to the dean’s office, and they notify faculty of meetings in writing. The English Department’s earlier memos and correspondence were archived for decades. IU’s answers so far have addressed only minutes while sidestepping my request for memorandum, correspondence, etc.

I’m preparing a new request for memoranda and communication from 2000 to 2006, along with the retention schedules and Archives transfer records that would show where they went.

The Public Access Counselor found that IU didn’t violate the law, because IU says the records don’t exist and the Counselor can’t force an agency to produce records it says it doesn’t have. I understand that. But when a public university’s account of its own records keeps changing, and its own records and website contradict it, the public has no way to know what’s true without help.

Why are the members of the Indiana University Bloomington Department of English and the Office of Vice President and General Counsel behaving like a bunch of paranoid drug dealers? It's not like I am asking them to release the Epstein files. I’ll keep asking, and I’ll post updates.

→